| Dec 1, 2024 | Colts at Patriots | IND 25, NE 24 | Colts won | 2024 regular season, Week 13 |
| Nov 12, 2023 | Colts at Patriots | IND 10, NE 6 | Colts won | 2023 regular season, Week 10 |
| Nov 6, 2022 | Colts at Patriots | IND 3, NE 26 | Patriots won | 2022 regular season, Week 9 |
| Dec 18, 2021 | Patriots at Colts | NE 17, IND 27 | Colts won | 2021 regular season, Week 15 |
| Oct 4, 2018 | Colts at Patriots | IND 24, NE 38 | Patriots won | 2018 regular season, Week 5 |
| Oct 18, 2015 | Patriots at Colts | NE 34, IND 27 | Patriots won | 2015 regular season, Week 6 |
| Jan 18, 2015 | Colts at Patriots | IND 7, NE 45 | Patriots won | 2014 postseason |
| Nov 16, 2014 | Patriots at Colts | NE 42, IND 20 | Patriots won | 2014 regular season, Week 11 |
| Jan 11, 2014 | Colts at Patriots | IND 22, NE 43 | Patriots won | 2013 postseason |
| Nov 18, 2012 | Colts at Patriots | IND 24, NE 59 | Patriots won | 2012 regular season, Week 11 |
| Dec 4, 2011 | Colts at Patriots | IND 24, NE 31 | Patriots won | 2011 regular season, Week 13 |
| Nov 21, 2010 | Colts at Patriots | IND 28, NE 31 | Patriots won | 2010 regular season, Week 11 |
| Nov 15, 2009 | Patriots at Colts | NE 34, IND 35 | Colts won | 2009 regular season, Week 10 |
| Nov 2, 2008 | Patriots at Colts | NE 15, IND 18 | Colts won | 2008 regular season, Week 9 |
| Nov 4, 2007 | Patriots at Colts | NE 24, IND 20 | Patriots won | 2007 regular season, Week 9 |
| Jan 21, 2007 | Patriots at Colts | NE 34, IND 38 | Colts won | 2006 postseason |
| Nov 5, 2006 | Colts at Patriots | IND 27, NE 20 | Colts won | 2006 regular season, Week 9 |
| Nov 7, 2005 | Colts at Patriots | IND 40, NE 21 | Colts won | 2005 regular season, Week 9 |
| Jan 16, 2005 | Colts at Patriots | IND 3, NE 20 | Patriots won | 2004 postseason |
| Sep 9, 2004 | Colts at Patriots | IND 24, NE 27 | Patriots won | 2004 regular season, Week 1 |
| Jan 18, 2004 | Colts at Patriots | IND 14, NE 24 | Patriots won | 2003 postseason |
| Nov 30, 2003 | Patriots at Colts | NE 38, IND 34 | Patriots won | 2003 regular season, Week 13 |
| Oct 21, 2001 | Patriots at Colts | NE 38, IND 17 | Patriots won | 2001 regular season, Week 6 |
| Sep 30, 2001 | Colts at Patriots | IND 13, NE 44 | Patriots won | 2001 regular season, Week 3 |
| Oct 22, 2000 | Patriots at Colts | NE 23, IND 30 | Colts won | 2000 regular season, Week 8 |
| Oct 8, 2000 | Colts at Patriots | IND 16, NE 24 | Patriots won | 2000 regular season, Week 6 |
| Dec 12, 1999 | Patriots at Colts | NE 15, IND 20 | Colts won | 1999 regular season, Week 14 |
| Sep 19, 1999 | Colts at Patriots | IND 28, NE 31 | Patriots won | 1999 regular season, Week 2 |